Old Ice House Tavern Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to the charming Old Ice House Tavern, located at 1550 Walnut St, New Castle, IN, where rich history meets delicious eats. This fantastic local spot is best known for its mouthwatering offerings, particularly the standout steak burger and a variety of sandwiches, including the double hamburger and breaded tenderloin.

• Double Hamburger - $5.00
• Steak Sandwich - $4.75
• Grilled Tenderloin Sandwich - $3.75
• Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich - $4.75

Patrons rave about the vibrant atmosphere and friendly service, with highlights including homemade horseradish and superb mushrooms. Whether you’re in for a meal or a drink, the Old Ice House Tavern promises a memorable experience that feels like home.